Please select your home edition
Edition
Bakewell-White Yacht Design

America's Cup- New Protocol represents a substantial shift in rules

by Richard Gladwell, Sail-World.com/nz on 4 Jun 2014
America’s Cup final, Emirates Team New Zealand and Oracle Team USA - Race 16 Carlo Borlenghi/Luna Rossa© http://www.lunarossachallenge.com
While the official release notes many of the high level features of the Protocol for the 35th America's Cup, a quick reading of the lengthy document which will govern the 2017 regatta reveals substantial change from the preceding event.

The entry fee has been set at $2 million, payable in two installments, as well an additional Performance Bond of $1 million is required. Entry fees were initially substantial for the last America's Cup and were slashed, when the numbers of Challengers did not eventuate. The new levels seem to be set to encourage only well-funded teams

Only the top four Teams will proceed to sail in the America's Cup Finals at the event venue. The Challengers will have to sail a series elsewhere, which has been previously condemned as unworkable by many due to the difficulties that creates for sponsor exposure. The venue and dates for the 35th Match will be announced by December 31, 2014.

The Defender appointed and controlled America's Cup Event Authority will conduct the selection process for the Challenger Play-Off's round. It is not clear how far in advance of the Finals this will be scheduled. Of course, Challengers will have to launch their boat well in advance of the play-off's, work it up, and then take the same boat to the match venue, sail a further series of races, and then one will go on to compete in the Match - all sailing just the one boat.

The timing of the Play-off stage of the America's Cup has not been announced. The teams will not be able to launch their AC62 until 150 days before the start of the Play-offs.

The selection of the Play-off venue will be handled by ACEA and will no doubt attract a Venue Fee. ACEA in conjunction with the Challenger of Record and Competitors Forum shall decide the Play-off venue.

An America's Cup Qualification series will be held which will bring forward points into the play-offs depending on the number of entries. It would seem that entry into the ACQ series will be restricted only to bonafide America's Cup Challengers and Defender, however other teams may be allowed to compete as last time in the ACWS when the Challenger numbers were insufficient to make an event.

The Nationality rule requires only a minimum of two crew on aboard an AC62 and only requires the crew to have a passport in the country of their club, on this basis with many competitors carrying dual passports or being entitled to do so, this is not a significant change.

Jury gone
The International Jury has gone and been replaced by a three person Arbitration Panel chosen from Court of Arbitration of Sport. The powers of the Arbitration Panel are limited. The America's Cup organisers have yet to conclude an arrangement with the world sailing body. It is not clear who will actually adjudicate on Racing Rule infringements, in the Protocol the Umpires are expected to adjudicate on racing rule decisions. The proposed system is the same as that used in the 2000 and 2003 America's Cups. The rationale then was to set up an arbitration body to keep issues out of the Courts, and the cut-off between the Arbitration Panel and the Int Jury was that the former handled Protocol related issues and the latter handled racing rule issues, but there were issues when both the Protocol and Racing Rules applied to a case.

For later Cups the dual body concept was dropped in favour of a single International Jury selected and appointed by the International Sailing Federation. That independence of the Jury was the only defence the Challengers had against the Defenders - who for the first time lost two significant Hearings and had five of their team named for cheating, The Int Jury also levied a $250,000 fine against the Defenders and docked them two points in the Match.

The Panel has been set up legally as an Arbitration body and has its seat in the State of New York legal system, which is also the home of the 18th century Deed of Gift that governs the America's Cup. However that terminology also surrounded the International Jury in the 2013 America's Cup.

ISAF Rules provide for the appointment of an Intentional Jury for the America's Cup with its members to be appointed by the ISAF. It would seem that America's Cup organisers are on a collision course with ISAF, unless there are substantial changes. The Protocol says that the racing rules will be agreed between the Challenger or Record and Defender and published by November 1, 2014. It is not clear if these will be the ISAF Rules, or the the ISAF AC Rules (used in AC43) or some other concoction.

A new function, the Commercial Commissioner has been created to make commercial decisions on all aspects of the four series.

The Measurement Committee will not be subject to review by the Arbitration Panel and its decision will be final. It is not clear if there would still be recourse to the Arbitration Panel in a situation where in AC34 the Measurement Committee, supported by Oracle and Artemis, ruled that foilers were effectively illegal. It was only Emirates Team NZ and Luna Rossa, supported by the Regatta Director who took the Measurement Committee to the Int Jury who held that the Measurement Committee had exceeded its authority and had effectively written a new class rule, which they were not entitled to do. No such automatic recourse is available under this latest Protocol, save for a claim that the Measurement Committee had exceeded its jurisdiction or authority.

A Regatta Director will be appointed to handle race management of all events. While the Protocol is long on commercial rights, there is no mention of distribution of any surplus revenue to the Teams. Additionally the teams are restricted to the use of social media and websites etc that are not part of the Event media, and are controlled by ACEA.

One of the most disturbing aspects of the Protocol is that all officials are appointed by the Defender, and can be removed at any time by the Defender, the exception being members of the Arbitration Panel who can only be removed by the Defender and Challenger of Record. The costs of officials are now to be shared amongst the competitors, yet the right of hire and fire rest solely with the Defender.

The appointment of key officials in the International Jury and Umpiring team by the International Sailing Federation, independently of organisers, gave considerable protection to the independence of key officials, and that has now been removed.

ISAF has long stood for independence of adjudication and fairness, with competitors operating within the sidelines of a level playing field. That basic tenet appears to have been removed, and there is far less mention of the world body in the current Protocol than that which applied for the 34th Cup.

Erasure of ISAF from any major sailing event is a very serious issue, particularly when this flies in the face of ISAF's own Regulations. Sanctions on the event, and those involved, would be an expected consequence. In the first instance it would probably fall to the US body, US Sailing to pull their member club, Golden Gate Yacht Club into line. Teams with 2016 Olympic sailors in them, who have entered the 35th America's Cup, could also find themselves in hot-water with the world sailing body.

Boat rules:
The Defender will be allowed two boats and the Challengers only one. Both Defenders and Challenger boats shall be subject to a hull alteration rule of 20%. (Presumably both Defender boats could have different alterations and stay within the 20% - they do have to initially come from the one mould). In the event of the Defender's first boat being damaged and not being able to be repaired, they can use their second boat. The Challengers have no such rights in the event of major damage in the Match or preceding events.

The wind limits have been changed to 25kts True Wind Speed instead of the ridiculous system of an Apparent Wind Speed Limit used in the last America's Cup. The lower limit is 5kts.

There are no limits on observation of competitors - the Defender can get as close as it likes to Challengers on the water and vice versa.

The Surrogate Boat rule remains as it was for AC34 - i.e., less than 33ft, or an AC45. It is not known if the AC45's can be modified to include foiling versions. There is provision for the AC45's to be adapted to become foilers in the last round of the Qualifiers.

The Protocol can be changed with the consent of the Defender, the Challenger of record and the majority of the Competitor Forum.

The early reaction from Team New Zealand is that they accepted that the America's Cup might be moving outside the reach of the commercially funded teams with requisites for USD$3million in Entry Fees and Performance Bonds before the venue is announced.

New Zealand responses and comment:

For Peter Montgomery's comments click here

Team New Zealand's Grant Dalton is flying back from Europe to New Zealand but spoke with NewstalkZB this morning, click here to listen

Team New Zealand indicated they may make a statement later today, but would prefer to leave the question of their participation until the senior members of the team had met face to face and discussed the issues.

And for the last word from TVNZ's Mike Hosking as he closed the Seven Sharp prime time news tonight:

'If the America's Cup ever wants to be taken seriously, why when they launch the new Protocol, as they did today do they insist on bringing in rules that can cause nothing but derision?

'Oracle get to have two boats - everybody else gets one. How can you possibly dream up a rule as dumb as that, and keep a straight face?

'Having been in San Francisco and seen first hand what is possible in the sport. Having seen this country gripped by the magic of the Cup and having listened to Russell Coutts promise a more open and fair contest, this rule makes a joke of all that.

'Sort the venue, Get the cost down, get a bunch of entries, let everybody compete on a level playing field, and stop being a bunch of dicks.'

On the other channel in the same time slot, the Protocol was described as 'bizzare' by John Campbell, the show host.

The Protocol was a prime time news item on both NZ channels, and was lead item in the primetime evening news on Click here for 3News sports item on the America's Cup Protocol and click here for the report from OneNews.
Zhik ZKG 660x82Ancasta Ker 33 660x82Barz Optics - San Juan Worlds Best Eyewear

Related Articles

Rio 2016 - America's Cup champ says Paralympic racing is closest ever
Twice America’s Cup champion, Rick Dodson is extremely impressed with the standard of racing in the three man Sonar Twice America’s Cup champion, Rick Dodson is extremely impressed with the standard of racing in the three man Sonar keelboat class at the 2016 Paralympics in Rio de Janeiro. The regatta is being held in Guanabara Bay on three of the courses used for the Olympic Sailing Regatta in August.
Posted on 13 Sep
Debriefing the Rio 2016 Olympics with Team USA’s Helena Scutt
I talked with Team USA’s Helena Scutt to hear about her Olympic experience, and to learn more about her post-Rio plans. The 49erFX was introduced to Olympic circles when it replaced the Women’s Match Racing event following the 2012 Games. Not surprisingly, it drew high-performance sailors for the Rio 2016 Olympics, including Team USA’s Paris Henken and Helena Scutt. While Henken and Scutt were Olympic first-timers, they put on a strong show. I caught up with Scutt to hear more about her Olympic experience.
Posted on 8 Sep
A Q&A with Peter Bresnan ONE Palma’s founder and director
Sail-World interviewed ONE Palma’s founder Peter Bresnan to learn about the company’s partnership with McConaghy Boats For the past eight years, ONE Palma (formerly OneSails Spain) has been building a strong name, first as a sailmaker and later with refit work. Recently, ONE Palma and McConaghy Boats-legendary boatbuilders who have crafted some of the planet’s fastest sailboats-entered a business partnership. I caught up with Peter Bresnan, ONE Palma’s founder and director, to learn more about this new direction.
Posted on 2 Sep
America's Cup - Emirates Team NZ train late on the Waitemata Harbour
Emirates Team NZ were out for a training session that ran into the early Thursday evening. Emirates Team NZ were out for a training session that ran into the early Thursday evening. The team were sailing their recently launched AC45 Surrogate test boat which features an articulated rudder gantry - taking the AC45 close to the geometry of the AC50 to be used in the 2017 America's Cup.
Posted on 1 Sep
Dateline Rio - Sailing Olympics review - as good as it gets?
The Rio Sailing Olympics was widely judged to have been the best of recent times. The Rio Sailing Olympics was widely judged to have been the best of recent times. The weather was better than Weymouth and Qingdao, the courses more varied, but from a working media perspective, it was the people running the Rio regatta who really made the difference.
Posted on 26 Aug
Rio 2016 - Plain speaking by triple-medalist on Olympic sailing moves
Triple Olympic medalist, Santiago Lange has been on the sharp end of changes made to Olympic classes and formats Santiago Lange, a six-time Olympian and Bronze medallist in the 2004 and 2008 Olympics, won his third medal – Gold sailing in the Nacra 17 class. With that length of experience at an Olympic level, having sailed the Laser, Tornado and now Nacra 17 classes his comments on the future shape of the Olympic regatta was one of the highlights of the Medallists Media Conferences.
Posted on 25 Aug
An Q&A with Steve and Heidi Benjamin about the NYYC’s 2016 Queen’s Cup
Sail-World caught up with Steve and Heidi Benjamin to learn more about Heidi’s historic win in the NYYC’s Queen’s Cup. When it comes to U.S. Grand Prix sailing, it’s hard not to encounter the names of Steve and Heidi Benjamin. The two highly polished sailors have been successfully campaigning their series of yachts, named SPOOKIE, for years, starting first with a Carkeek 40 and progressing to their TP52. I caught up with Steve and Heidi to learn more about Heidi’s historic win in the NYYC’s Queen’s Cup
Posted on 19 Aug
Rio 2016 - Images of the penultimate race in the Finns - Scott wins
Sail-World's Richard Gladwell was on the water for the final race of the Qualifying Series of the Mens Finn Sail-World's Richard Gladwell was on the water for the final race of the Qualifying Series of the Mens Finn, in what potentially could have been Giles Scott's (GBR) Gold medal winning race. In the end, the current world champion won in style.
Posted on 15 Aug
Rio 2016 - Images from the Mens RS:X Medal Race
Sail-World's NZ Editor, Richard Gladwell, was on the water at the Medal Race for the RS:X class Sail-World's NZ Editor, Richard Gladwell, was on the water at the Medal Race for the RS:X class won before the race by Dorian van Rijsselberghe (NED) without needing points from the Medal Race. Nick Dempsey (GBR) was second on a similar basis.
Posted on 15 Aug
Rio 2016 - Sailors talk of Life at the Extreme on the Atlantic Ocean
Certainly the Volvo Ocean Race catchcry of Life at the Extreme is not a phrase associated with the Sailing Olympics. The 470 crews were suffering the mixed emotions of survival of an extreme test by nature, the cold, and for some elation at their placings, after Thursday's battle for survival. In conditions that looked more out of the Volvo Ocean Race, than an Olympic sailing regatta, crews battled 20kt plus winds and Atlantic Ocean rollers that towered up to four metres.
Posted on 13 Aug