Please select your home edition
Edition
Protector 728x90

America's Cup- Emirates Team NZ/Luna Rossa deal gets a tick from Jury

by Richard Gladwell on 1 Jan 2012
Emirates Team NZ have substantially prevailed in the decisions handed down over their partnership arrangements with Luna Rossa © Richard Gladwell www.photosport.co.nz

The International Jury has answered the first of a two stage challenge to the joint development and training agreement between the two America's Cup teams, Emirates Team New Zealand and the new Italian Challenger Luna Rossa.

In a ruling released after Christmas to a series of eight, or rather nine, as one was in two parts, questions put forward by the defender Oracle Racing, the Int Jury has sanctioned most of the key points in the unpublished agreement which would have covered design and development.

The Defender, backed by one of the IT billionaire, Larry Ellison, posed ten questions to the International Jury citing a potential arrangement between the Defender and an unnamed training/development partner.

At the time of lodgement of the questions to the Int Jury, the Challenger of Record, Artemis Racing stated that they would withhold their specific questions of the Luna Rossa and Emirates Team NZ arrangement, until they had seen the Int Jury's answers to the Defenders questions.

The kicker for Cup pundits is that while the questions, posed by Oracle Racing, are paraphrased in the Decision, the Application on which they are based has not been publicly released. The error most make is to lay this Decision, over the also not publicly released details of the Emirate Team NZ/Luna Rossa agreement (a summary of which was given to the Jury), and then start drawing conclusions. Making an assumption and then drawing conclusions is a practice best left to economic theorists, rather than being applied to the labyrinthine world of America's Cup Rules and their possibilities.

A very careful read of the Decision, along with the Protocol, plus an extraction of the references to the questions from Oracle Racing, show that the questions put were probably based on a somewhat looser arrangement, than that contemplated by Luna Rossa and Emirates Team NZ. In a couple of areas the Itiwi agreement might have to be tightened, in regard to boat construction to allow both teams to build two boats each. Essentially there has to be an arm's length relationship between the teams. But the point missed by most is that you shouldn't have to be told what you can already see. And, when two teams are working out of a common base, there isn't a lot that can't be seen.

It is a matter of conjecture whether this game of cat and mouse was genuinely an attempt to clarify the rules that both the Challenger and Defender signed off, or whether it is an attempt to thwart the efforts of two teams who between themselves have reached several America's Cup and Louis Vuitton Cup Finals, and were themselves Challenger and Defender in the 2000 America's Cup.

Three of the Challengers, Artemis, Emirates Team NZ and Luna Rossa made submissions to the Int Jury. Emirates Team NZ also submitted a summary of their partnership agreement to the Int Jury.

In essence, the Protocol signed by Artemis Racing representing the KSSS (Royal Swedish Yacht Club) and Oracle Racing representing Golden Gate Yacht Club, allowed joint design collaboration between teams up to 31 December 2012, after which they would have to work independently.

The wrinkle in the Protocol uncovered by Emirates Team NZ and Luna Rossa was that while the teams would have been allowed to build two new boats, by working together in a particular way they could get more out of that provision of the Protocol than was contemplated.

By building two boats to an identical design and working against each other, the two teams would obtain vital design and performance information which could then be laid off to good effect with the development of their second boats, which would have to be developed independently.

In normal circumstances, a team would have the choice of building two identical boats and then refining that platform. Or more commonly, building two slightly different boats - with the second being the development of the first. The partnership contemplated by Luna Rossa and Emirates Team New Zealand would give the teams the best of both options.

The International Jury has given the all clear on most of the keypoints that are revealed in close read of the Protocol by Cup strategists.

The only limitations that have been imposed are a requirement that all the boats be built by independent construction teams, and that the crews cannot swap between boats. Additionally parts such as foils cannot be swapped between teams. The sharing of tooling is permitted.

These limitations are only a slight smoothing of the wrinkle, as the America's Cup has always been governed by strict 'constructed in country' rules - which require the boats to be built in the country of the challenging or defending club.

But oddly, the tooling for the construction of the hulls of an America's Cup yacht can be built in a country other than the country of origin. In other words, Cooksons as builders of the AC72's for Emirates Team NZ, could also construct the tooling for the construction of the boats for Luna Rossa, however those parts would have to be flown to Italy for the boat to be laid up in the moulds, by an independent building team working on Italian soil.

But the yacht does not have to be launched in Italy, and the hulls could be flown back to NZ, assembled, have a NZ constructed wingsail stepped and then sailed against Emirates Team NZ's new boat before being shipped to San Francisco in April 2013 in preparation for the start of the Louis Vuiton Cup in July 2013.

To see the full decision http://noticeboard.americascup.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/JN024.pdf!click_here

SL33's ruled to be not Surrogates
In a somewhat unrelated decision, the International Jury has not surprisingly ruled that upon production of a measurement certificate stating that the SL33's used by Emirates Team NZ are 9.999metres long, that the catamarans used as a development platform by the Auckland based team, do not exceed the 10metre length restriction on the use of other similar, or surrogate, boats.

Emirates Team NZ put the initial question to the Jury, and there was no serious objection to the length overall being that of the hulls, however a delay in responding and needing an answer before 1 January 2012, has resulted in Emirates Team NZ being charged 5,000 Euros in Costs.

http://noticeboard.americascup.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/JN023.pdf!Click_here for the full decision on the SL33 eligibility.

Emirates Team NZ produced a statement from Ken McAlpine, a long-time and highly respected America's Cup measurer, stating that the length overall was the hull length and not that of the hull, plus add-ons. This view was accepted by the International Jury, who noted that Emirates Team NZ had already been sailing the SL33's for about six months.

Cup courses announced
The courses have been confirmed by the America's Cup organisers for the 34th Match and Louis Vuitton Cup in San Francisco. Essentially they will be the same configuration as those used for the America's Cup World Series - with a reaching start and finish and windward leewards in between. The course durations will be either 30 minutes or 50 minutes long.

To see the Course document http://noticeboard.americascup.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/Regatta-Notice-81-Courses-for-the-LVC-34th-America%E2%80%99s-Cup-Match1.pdf!click_here



Ancasta Ker 33 660x82Zhik Dinghy 660x82Mackay Boats

Related Articles

America's Cup - Emirates Team NZ give first look at the pedaling AC50
Emirates Team New Zealand formally christened their new AC50 America's Cup Challenger on a rainy Auckland afternoon. Emirates Team New Zealand formally christened their new AC50 America's Cup Challenger on a rainy Auckland afternoon. The team has been sailing for the previous two days making news headlines after it was revealed in Sail-World.com that the AC50 would become only the second yacht in America's Cup history to use pedal power.
Posted on 16 Feb
America's Cup - Kiwis sign Olympic Cyclist for the Tour de Bermuda
Ttop cyclist Simon van Velthooven, a 2012 Olympic Bronze cycling medallist had been signed by the America's Cup team Emirates Team New Zealand put in a second foiling display on Auckland's Waitemata harbour ahead of the official launching of their AC50 tomorrow. With brighter skies the cycling team took their places on the pedalstals and used leg power to provide the hydraulic pressure necessary to run the AC50's control systems for the foils and wingsail.
Posted on 15 Feb
A Q&A with Shawn Macking about the StPYC’s Sailing Center and OD fleet
I talked with Shawn Macking, the StPYC’s waterfront director, to learn how the club is getting more people out sailing. I caught up with Shawn Macking, waterfront director of the St. Petersburg Yacht Club, via email to learn more about the club’s Sailing Center, its hefty investment in a new fleet of ten J/70s, and how the StPYC is using this infrastructure to expose more people to the sport we all love.
Posted on 13 Feb
A Q&A with Karen Angle about the 2017 Conch Republic Cup race to Cuba
I caught up with Karen Angle, executive director of the Conch Republic Cup, to learn more about this exciting event. If you’re like me and have arrived at saturation with winter’s cold rain and snow, imagine racing to Cuba as part of a 13-day cross-cultural event that’s designed to lower barriers of entry at a time when some Americans see a need for taller walls. I caught up with Karen Angle, executive director of the Conch Republic Cup, to learn more about this exciting event and the adventures it affords.
Posted on 23 Jan
A Q&A with Anna Tunnicliffe about her return to competitive sailing
I talked with Anna Tunnicliffe before the Sailing World Cup Miami to learn about her return to Olympic-class sailing. Anna Tunnicliffe won gold at the Beijing 2008 Olympics in the Laser Radial before shifting her sights to the Women’s Match Racing event for the London 2012 Olympics. Here, she came up shy of expectation and left sailing for the CrossFit Games, but now she is returning to her roots. I talked with Tunnicliffe before the Sailing World Cup Miami to learn about her return to Olympic-class sailing.
Posted on 23 Jan
A Q&A with Dick Neville, Quantum Key West Race Week’s RC chairman
I caught up with Dick Neville, Race Committee chair for the Quantum Key West Race Week, to learn more about the event. For the past 30 years, international sailors have gathered in Key West, Florida, each January for Key West Race Week, a regatta that has achieved legendary status due to its calendar dates, its location, and the impressive level of competition and racecourse management that this storied event offers. I caught up with Dick Neville, Race Committee chair for this year’s Quantum KWRW, to learn more.
Posted on 16 Jan
A Q&A with Daniel Smith, the Clipper Race’s new deputy race director
I talked with Daniel Smith, the Clipper Round The World Race’s new deputy race director, to learn more about his role. I was fortunate to sail with Daniel Smith [36, SCO], skipper of “Derry~Londonderry~Doire” for the 2015/2016 edition of the Clipper Round The World Race, when the fleet reached Seattle last spring. Now, Smith has been hired as the event’s deputy race director-a job that will test many of the skills that he polished as a skipper. I caught up with Smith via email to learn more about his new job.
Posted on 9 Jan
Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race - Suck it up, sunshine!
The 72nd start of the iconic blue water classic had 300,000 spectators lining the foreshores of Sydney Harbour The 72nd start of the iconic blue water classic had 300,000 spectators lining the foreshores of Sydney Harbour, another two million watching on TV, and the constant buzz and whir of media helicopters overhead. 88 boats, from Australia, USA, UK, Germany, Sweden, Russia, Japan, Korea, China, oh and New Zealand, had lined up on three start lines.
Posted on 31 Dec 2016
Rolex Sydney Hobart Race - More merriment on the airwaves
Here are more examples of merriment on the airwaves between the boats and Hobart Race Control So on December 29, 2016, after the River Derwent had let just three boats home (Perpetual Loyal, Giacomo and Scallywag, all inside the old race record, she went to sleep for a lot of the day. This made it frustrating for the sailors, some of whom saw the lighter side. So after seeing some of those in Dark & Stormy, here are more examples of merriment on the airwaves between the boats and HRC
Posted on 29 Dec 2016
Sydney Hobart Race-Dark and stormy, well because it is Dark and Stormy
Proving that there is a lighter side to the frustrations that is a race to Hobart Well it is now dark and the rain 'storms' have passed, but proving that there is a lighter side to the frustrations that is a race to Hobart, the custom Murray 37, Dark & Stormy had a wonderful exchange on the radio. Quite possibly it was co-owner and Navigator Terry Courts on the VHF in the super-frank exchange with Hobart Race Control at around 1928hrs on 29/12/16.
Posted on 29 Dec 2016