Please select your home edition
Edition
Collinson and Co

London Olympics 2012 - Windsurfing's last hurrah

by Bob Fisher on 8 Aug 2012
Tuuli Petaja (FIN) who won SIlver Medal today, 07.08.12, in the Medal Race Women’s Windsurfer (RSX) event in The London 2012 Olympic Sailing Competition. onEdition © http://www.onEdition.com

The world's leading international sailing journalist, Bob Fisher, writes for Sail-World from Weymouth - venue for the 102 Olympic Sailing Regatta.


As the medal race of the Women's RS:X windsurfer was played out, the thoughts of many must have been with the competing women for whom this was a last hurrah in the five-ring circus. Those five competitors were probably cursing the idiocy of the ISAF Council that robbed them of the highest level participation for their sport. For those still in the dark, the Council of the International Sailing Federation at its mid-year meeting, voted to replace Windsurfing for Men and Women with Kiteboarding for both genders, by a single vote majority.

The back-tracking has been amusing, or would have been if it had not been such a blatant tissue of untruths. Who on earth would believe that a Councillor of ISAF could be confused about the voting to the extent that he gave his vote to the Kiteboards when he really wanted to vote for the retention of the Windsurfers? These are meant to be the custodians of our sport, but their record would disqualify them from running a charity shop.

As administrators they need to review their own record - getting rid of the Tornado catamaran at a time when the rest of the world was encouraging multihulls was a prime example of the extent the Councillors were out of touch, while introducing match racing for women for a single Olympiad is another. Now, it is to dispose of the only keel-boat class, the Star, where the most talented sailors were to be, and would have been, found. There is a grave danger of turning the Olympics into a junior regatta. Soccer-Moms, you could well find a place for yourselves in this sport (Council elections are in November}.

As the Women's RS:X race drew to its conclusion, it became increasingly obvious that Marina Alabau Neira of Spain would consolidate her leading position, take the gold medal and this situation was going to be embarrassing for the Spanish representative on the ISAF Council, Gerardo Pombo. For it was he who declared that he had been confused by the voting procedure and had voted for the Kiteboards when he had meant to support the Windsurfers. Or was this simply an attempt to save face when he returned home? Had he voted the way he said that he had meant to, there would definitely be windsurfing in Rio de Janeiro in 2016 and there would be smiles on the faces of all the windsurfers, men and women.


The paucity of Kiteboard events must (or should) cause concern to ISAF. It would appear that it is believed that the run-up to the 2016 Olympics is going to provide ISAF with all it needs to run two events in the pinnacle festival. That will be the sum of experience available - hardly enough, one suspects, to be satisfied that this discipline is fully understood. This might be enough for the kitesurfing to be considered for 2020, but the lack of experience for the next Games might result in a less-than-perfect event.

When interviewed after winning the gold medal, Marina Alabau said: 'I love windsurfing and I think kitesurfing is a big mistake and that windsurfing is the most exciting sailing sport. I think you could see that this week.' She added: 'Kitesurfing is a fantastic sport but not [for] racing, Freestyle is the newer sport but it is still not developed and they don't even have a one-design. I think windsurfing is best for sailing. There are a lot of countries that don't want the kite. If they put the kite in, it is going to be a big mistake and windsurfing will be back for 2020.'

Her fellow medallists agreed. Zofia Nocti-Klepacka of Poland, who won bronze, said: 'They [ISAF] think there are a million people doing kite racing - that is not true, there are more like 20. I hope that when they meet in November, they will change their minds.' Silver medallist Tuuli Petaja of Finland concurred: 'Windsurfing should stay. Course racing with kites is not a big sport yet.' They all pointed out that there are no provisions for younger people in kiteboarding.


Nick Dempsey, the British silver medallist was adamant that it would be a 'massive shame that we have been dropped. The RS:X sailors have shown this week how fair and close the racing has been.' Gold medallist Dorian van Russelberge agreed: 'We have the infrastructure for young people in Windsurfing, but nothing for kiteboarding. I hope windsurfing stays.'

With the pressure applied to ISAF from the sailors, a re-think should be on the cards, but the hidebound bureaucracy that surrounds the Federation may prevent the wish of the majority. Shame.

Hall Spars - BattenPantaenius - Fixed ValueHella Marine - July 2016

Related Articles

A Q&A with Anna Tunnicliffe about her return to competitive sailing
I talked with Anna Tunnicliffe before the Sailing World Cup Miami to learn about her return to Olympic-class sailing. Anna Tunnicliffe won gold at the Beijing 2008 Olympics in the Laser Radial before shifting her sights to the Women’s Match Racing event for the London 2012 Olympics. Here, she came up shy of expectation and left sailing for the CrossFit Games, but now she is returning to her roots. I talked with Tunnicliffe before the Sailing World Cup Miami to learn about her return to Olympic-class sailing.
Posted today at 5:07 pm
Rolex Sydney Hobart Race – Race record smashed
On Day Three (just) of the 72nd Rolex Sydney to Hobart Yacht Race Perpetual Loyal smashed the race record On Day Three (just) of the 72nd Rolex Sydney to Hobart Yacht Race, in the strongest downwind conditions in recent times, certainly as good as the 1999 iteration of the blue water classic, Anthony Bell’s supermaxi, Perpetual Loyal, the former Speedboat and then Rambler 100, smashed the race record for the famous 628-nautical mile event.
Posted on 27 Dec 2016
Rolex Sydney Hobart Race – right turn means record in mortal danger?
A while ago we talked about not unprecedented conditions, but certainly ones that had not been seen for ages. A while ago we talked about not unprecedented conditions, but certainly ones that had not been seen for ages. Those that did a lot of Hobarts in the 90s would scoff at the thought of using the kite sheets for the whole journey. Their memories would be why they even bothered to clip them onto the rail at all.
Posted on 27 Dec 2016
Rolex Sydney Hobart Race – The Derwent awake or asleep for Loyal?
With steady winds now pushing everyone down the Tasmanian East Coast With steady winds now pushing everyone down the Tasmanian East Coast, it does appear that barring a mechanical failure, Anthony Bell’s Perpetual Loyal will be the first boat into Storm Bay tonight, and well on record pace too!
Posted on 27 Dec 2016
AeroMedia Drone Video from Rolex Sydney Hobart Race start
Jono Whiity drives the 18-Footer, Line 7, and also pilots the hAeroMedia drone for these images of the #RSHYR start. Jono Whiity drives the 18-Footer, Line 7, and also pilots the AeroMedia drone that captured these images of the #RSHYR start.
Posted on 27 Dec 2016
Rolex Sydney Hobart Race – Situation normal
You could easily say that all is right with the world again. You could easily say that all is right with the world again. After the worst start in 12 years, the Oatley family’s 100 foot Wild Oats XI, the eight times line honours winner skippered by Mark Richards is leading the fleet South, as she has done so many, many times before.
Posted on 26 Dec 2016
Rolex Sydney Hobart Race – Changing of the guard
So as darkness descends on the Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race, watch systems and red lights take over from sunglasses So as darkness descends on the 72nd Rolex Sydney Hobart Yacht Race, watch systems and red lights take the place of sunglasses and hats. Yet another of the Hobart maxims is now coming into play. You go out early and come in late. It means you stay offshore early to pick up the East Australia Current running down South and then come in back to the Tasmanian coast and stay there.
Posted on 26 Dec 2016
Wild Oats XI Training Day - VIDEO
As your Christmas Day preparations get into full swing, chances are you won’t have much time to get into the mood As your Christmas Day preparations get into full swing, chances are you won’t have much time to get into the mood for the big race to Hobart on Boxing Day. So here’s a pacey one minute video we've compiled from a training day that we shot aboard Wild Oats XI this time last year in a solid nor'easter, shortly after her major rebuild was completed. Merry Christmas to all from Crosbie and Dale
Posted on 23 Dec 2016
Aon Youth Worlds - Images from Day 2 - 420 and Drone
Sail-World NZ's editor, Richard Gladwell was on the water for Day 2 of the Aon Youth World sailing Championship Sail-World NZ's editor, Richard Gladwell was on the water for Day 2 of the Aon Youth World sailing Championship off Torbay on Auckland's North Shore. Here's the gallery of images from the 420's along with a couple of images of the Drone launch and retrieval
Posted on 17 Dec 2016
America's Cup - More retrospective rule changes split Challengers
The America's Cup Competitors Forum pushed through more retrospective Protocol changes at a meeting The America's Cup Competitors Forum pushed through more retrospective Protocol changes at a meeting believed to have been held in Fukuoka at the time of the America's Cup World Series held in the City. One of the retrospective rule changes gives clear advantage to competitors who have opted to adopt the risky strategy of designing and developing light air and heavy air foiling daggerboards for the
Posted on 13 Dec 2016