Please select your home edition
Edition
Zhik Seaboot

Dianshan Lake Winter Match Racing Regatta- An Uncalled-for Penalty

by China Boating Intelligence (CBI) on 29 Nov 2013
Briefing on the alternative rules of Match Racing. Mr Liu rearranges the Rules for the Dianshan Lake event China Boating Intelligence (CBI)
With the Monsoon Cup presently running in Kuala Terengganu, Asian sailors are getting an eyeful of match racing at the moment. And on that subject, here’s a question from one of the spectators at the recent Dianshan Lake Winter Match Racing Regatta, 23-24 November: When is a penalty not a penalty?

'In one of the early matches, one boat sailed to leeward of the other, no room asked or given, and certainly no 'Y' flag from either team. This was confirmed by one of the other people on the umpire boat. So imagine this viewer’s surprise when suddenly a blue flag shot up on the umpire boat. ?

(The Dianshan Lake Regatta organisers claimed that the rules were the same as the China Club Challenge Match (CCCM) run just two weeks earlier, with the event 'managed by a referee (sic) from the CCCM').

On coming ashore a rightly aggrieved Shanghai Airport team asked 'why the penalty when there was no Y flag?' to be told by Mr Liu QiDong that 'If neither boat raises a flag in a boat-on-boat situation then the umpires can give a penalty if they think there should be one.' When it was suggested that this wasn’t the case, Mr Liu informed the team that the rules had changed with the 2013 update'.

Sorry, Mr Liu, but as one of the bloggers suggested on Chinese Weibo social media site, you must have a cheap Chinese copy of the Racing Rules of Sailing! The RRS 2013-2016, Appendix C Rule C6.5(A) clearly states 'After flag Y is displayed, the umpires shall decide whether to penalize any boat.' In other words the umpires cannot penalize a boat-on-boat incident without a ‘Y’ flag. We checked with an America’s Cup jury member, as well as a former member of the ISAF Rules Committee, both of whom agree that this is a very basic error and is clearly in conflict with the fundamental umpiring concept of ‘No Flag – No Foul’.

They also clarified that an umpire can give a penalty on certain occasions, including contact with a mark (Rule 31), illegal propulsion (Rule 42), starting errors (in other words being in the box early or not over the start line at two minutes to go), and finally non-compliance with either a second existing penalty or a red flag penalty. In all other cases the aggrieved boat must fly a ‘Y’ flag before a penalty can be given.

Background info: Race Management was led by Lu QiDong, know in English as ‘Tony, who had indeed been a Race Officer of the CCCM in the past, which involved him setting the course and raising and lowering flags - but at no time had he umpired a match in the event.

In fact, such was his performance at the Club Cup that, as the event grew, he was not up to the task and a number of years ago he was replaced even in his relatively minor role. This replacement roughly coincided with Lu QiDong being ‘dropped’ by the CYA (Chinese Yachting Association) after a 470 sailor died during an event at which he was Principal Race Officer.

At the Dianshan Regatta skipper’s briefing Mr Lu declared that no boat was allowed into the ‘box’ before four minutes – the actual rule states that they must be ‘outside the box AT four minutes’ which any match racer knows is more than a small difference.

We would like to believe that the organizers simply believed what they were told by Lu QiDong, but when they were informed that his claim of experience was clearly untrue they declined to issue a correction to potential competitors.
It is sad that someone who obviously doesn’t understand the rules to a basic level should use the name of China’s top match racing event (the China Club Challenge) to further their own ends at the expense of competitors who entered this local event in good faith.

Alistair Skinner, who has been part of the umpire team of the China Club Challenge Match for each of the past seven years, confirmed that Mr Lu QiDong has never umpired any match at this event (which next year reaches its 10th birthday). Additionally, Mr. Skinner resents the reputation for accuracy and fair play that the Club Cup has built up over the years being abused for personal gain by an individual in this manner, and is concerned by the potential damage to the Club Cup’s reputation by such a poorly policed event claiming to be run by the same team, which it clearly wasn’t.
On the other hand, perhaps when sailors sit back and compare the two events it will only serve to further boost the already high reputation of the China Club Challenge Match.

[For the record, the author of this story was NOT part of the team incorrectly penalised. Ed]
Kiwi Yachting - Lewmar 660 - 1Lancer Industries - Lasts LongerFremantle to Bali Race 660x82

Related Articles

2016 J70 World Championship - Day 3
Two races were held today on Berkeley Circle for the J70 fleet. The first one was in non-planing conditions Two races were held today on Berkeley Circle for the J70 fleet. The first one was in non-planing conditions of eight - twelve knots and the second had winds of fifteen - twenty knots.
Posted today at 4:44 am
Split personality conditions at Day 3 of the 2016 Alcatel J/70 Worlds
Mother Nature had some surprises in store for the 68 boats that assembled on the Berkeley Circle for third day of racing Mother Nature had some surprises in store for the 68 boats that assembled on the Berkeley Circle for the third day of racing at the 2016 Alcatel J/70 Worlds, hosted by St. Francis Yacht Club, namely split personality conditions that tested each boat's light- and heavy-air skills, as well as their patience as conditions played tricks on racers and the Race Committee alike.
Posted today at 3:43 am
Collinson FX Market Commentary - Sept 29 - Reds back oil pumping cuts
Opec plus Russia reached an agreement to cut oil production overnight which allowed the price to move back to $47/barrel Opec plus Russia reached an agreement to cut oil production overnight which allowed the price to move back to $47/barrel. They do not have the sway of the cartels from the past and solidarity will be desperately hard to pursue.
Posted today at 12:55 am
Groupama Race – The first Caledonians at Home
A beautiful performance for the kiwis on their Eliott 50. Their complete the Groupama Race in four days 10h and 24 min. A beautiful performance for the kiwis on their Eliott 50. Their complete the Groupama Race in four days 10h and 24 min after nearly 300 NM of 'Match Racing' against local sailors.
Posted on 29 Sep
First all-female Extreme Sailing Series™ team to compete in Lisbon
First all-female GC32 team will make its debut at the penultimate event of the year in Lisbon in just one week’s time. The first all-female GC32 team, Thalassa Magenta Racing in partnership with the Magenta Project, will make its debut at the penultimate event of the year in Lisbon in just one week’s time.
Posted on 29 Sep
Sébastien Josse's lead up to the Vendée Globe
The skipper of the Mono60 Edmond de Rothschild is setting sail on his fifth round the world in 14 years. The skipper of the Mono60 Edmond de Rothschild is setting sail on his fifth round the world in 14 years. As such, the sailor can rely on a vast amount of experience, bolstered by all the expertise of the Gitana Team, the offshore racing stable founded in 2000 by Ariane and Benjamin de Rothschild
Posted on 29 Sep
Auckland On the Water Boat Show opens full of the Joys of Spring
The Auckland On the Water Boat Show enjoyed a beautiful Spring day for its opening. Despite the inclement weather that has been the New Zealand's daily fare for too long, the Auckland On the Water Boat Show enjoyed a beautiful Spring day for its opening. Today was the first of the four-day show and is also the first time that the Show has been held in the school holidays.
Posted on 29 Sep
Building conditions on Day 2 of the 2016 Alcatel J/70 Worlds
San Francisco has a storied reputation as a world-class venue during summer/early fall, and Day 2 of Alcatel J/70 Worlds San Francisco has a storied reputation as a world-class venue during the summer and early fall, and Day Two of the 2016 Alcatel J/70 Worlds, hosted by the St. Francis Yacht Club, did not disappoint.
Posted on 29 Sep
Groupama Race – Between the north and Nouméa
Beau Geste arrived at 7:09am this morning, taking the third position on real-time, behind Vodafone and Scallywag. Beau Geste arrived at 7:09am this morning, taking the third position on real-time, behind Vodafone and Scallywag. The crew was very pleased about his race. The owner and skipper, Karl Kwok, compared the luxury and unspoilt landscapes from the East coast to Polynesia and the West coast to Cebu island in Philippines.
Posted on 28 Sep
Les Voiles de St Tropez - Eugenia Bakunova's view of Day 2
Not a lot of wind for the second day of racing at Les Voiles de St Tropez. Not a lot of wind for the second day of racing at Les Voiles de St Tropez. Eugenia Bakunova of mainsail.ru captured these images of the always picturesque classics as they sailed in a light breeze
Posted on 28 Sep