Please select your home edition
Edition
North Sails  Got Tough

Dianshan Lake Winter Match Racing Regatta- An Uncalled-for Penalty

by China Boating Intelligence (CBI) on 29 Nov 2013
Briefing on the alternative rules of Match Racing. Mr Liu rearranges the Rules for the Dianshan Lake event China Boating Intelligence (CBI)
With the Monsoon Cup presently running in Kuala Terengganu, Asian sailors are getting an eyeful of match racing at the moment. And on that subject, here’s a question from one of the spectators at the recent Dianshan Lake Winter Match Racing Regatta, 23-24 November: When is a penalty not a penalty?

'In one of the early matches, one boat sailed to leeward of the other, no room asked or given, and certainly no 'Y' flag from either team. This was confirmed by one of the other people on the umpire boat. So imagine this viewer’s surprise when suddenly a blue flag shot up on the umpire boat. ?

(The Dianshan Lake Regatta organisers claimed that the rules were the same as the China Club Challenge Match (CCCM) run just two weeks earlier, with the event 'managed by a referee (sic) from the CCCM').

On coming ashore a rightly aggrieved Shanghai Airport team asked 'why the penalty when there was no Y flag?' to be told by Mr Liu QiDong that 'If neither boat raises a flag in a boat-on-boat situation then the umpires can give a penalty if they think there should be one.' When it was suggested that this wasn’t the case, Mr Liu informed the team that the rules had changed with the 2013 update'.

Sorry, Mr Liu, but as one of the bloggers suggested on Chinese Weibo social media site, you must have a cheap Chinese copy of the Racing Rules of Sailing! The RRS 2013-2016, Appendix C Rule C6.5(A) clearly states 'After flag Y is displayed, the umpires shall decide whether to penalize any boat.' In other words the umpires cannot penalize a boat-on-boat incident without a ‘Y’ flag. We checked with an America’s Cup jury member, as well as a former member of the ISAF Rules Committee, both of whom agree that this is a very basic error and is clearly in conflict with the fundamental umpiring concept of ‘No Flag – No Foul’.

They also clarified that an umpire can give a penalty on certain occasions, including contact with a mark (Rule 31), illegal propulsion (Rule 42), starting errors (in other words being in the box early or not over the start line at two minutes to go), and finally non-compliance with either a second existing penalty or a red flag penalty. In all other cases the aggrieved boat must fly a ‘Y’ flag before a penalty can be given.

Background info: Race Management was led by Lu QiDong, know in English as ‘Tony, who had indeed been a Race Officer of the CCCM in the past, which involved him setting the course and raising and lowering flags - but at no time had he umpired a match in the event.

In fact, such was his performance at the Club Cup that, as the event grew, he was not up to the task and a number of years ago he was replaced even in his relatively minor role. This replacement roughly coincided with Lu QiDong being ‘dropped’ by the CYA (Chinese Yachting Association) after a 470 sailor died during an event at which he was Principal Race Officer.

At the Dianshan Regatta skipper’s briefing Mr Lu declared that no boat was allowed into the ‘box’ before four minutes – the actual rule states that they must be ‘outside the box AT four minutes’ which any match racer knows is more than a small difference.

We would like to believe that the organizers simply believed what they were told by Lu QiDong, but when they were informed that his claim of experience was clearly untrue they declined to issue a correction to potential competitors.
It is sad that someone who obviously doesn’t understand the rules to a basic level should use the name of China’s top match racing event (the China Club Challenge) to further their own ends at the expense of competitors who entered this local event in good faith.

Alistair Skinner, who has been part of the umpire team of the China Club Challenge Match for each of the past seven years, confirmed that Mr Lu QiDong has never umpired any match at this event (which next year reaches its 10th birthday). Additionally, Mr. Skinner resents the reputation for accuracy and fair play that the Club Cup has built up over the years being abused for personal gain by an individual in this manner, and is concerned by the potential damage to the Club Cup’s reputation by such a poorly policed event claiming to be run by the same team, which it clearly wasn’t.
On the other hand, perhaps when sailors sit back and compare the two events it will only serve to further boost the already high reputation of the China Club Challenge Match.

[For the record, the author of this story was NOT part of the team incorrectly penalised. Ed]
Barz Optics - Kids rangePredictWind.com 2014Make Fast Moorings

Related Articles

Vendée Globe – Romain Attanasio at the Horn
Romain Attanasio (Famille Mary-Étamine du Lys) rounded Cape Horn, the third of the legendary capes at 2043hrs UTC Romain Attanasio (Famille Mary-Étamine du Lys) rounded Cape Horn, the third of the legendary capes at 2043hrs UTC on Friday after 75 days eight hours and 41 minutes of racing. Only Dutchman Pieter Heerema and Frenchman Sébastien Destremau are still sailing in the Pacific.
Posted today at 7:28 pm
Day 77 – Ninety percent of Vendée Globe fleet now back in Atlantic
With Banque Populaire and Hugo Boss tied up to the dock in Les Sables d'Olonne sixteen skippers remain at sea today With Le Cléac'h's Banque Populaire and second-placed Alex Thomson's Hugo Boss tied up to the dock in Les Sables d'Olonne sixteen skippers remain at sea today – and fourteen of them are now in the Atlantic.
Posted today at 5:53 pm
Vendee Globe - Romain Attansio at the Horn
Romain Attanasio rounded Cape Horn, the third of the legendary capes in the Vendée Globe at 2043hrs UTC on Friday Romain Attanasio (Famille Mary-Étamine du Lys) rounded Cape Horn, the third of the legendary capes in the Vendée Globe at 2043hrs UTC on Friday after 75 days 8 hours and 41 minutes of racing. Only Dutchman Pieter Heerema and Frenchman Sébastien Destremau are still sailing in the Pacific.
Posted today at 8:58 am
Thomson finishes Vendee Globe a close second powered by Doyle Stratis
After 74 days at sea Alex Thomson on Hugo Boss has taken out second place, gaining a coveted podium space What a sailor, what a race. In the fastest Vendee Globe in history, after 74 days at sea Alex Thomson on Hugo Boss has taken out second place, gaining a coveted podium space and finishing just 16 hours behind race winner Armel Le Cléac’h on Banque Populaire.
Posted on 20 Jan
Collinson FX Market Commentary - Jan 21 - New era begins for US
The weaker reserve, allowed the AUD to move to 0.7550, while the NZD held 0.7150. Trump is President and a new era begins. The new administration has outlined a broad outlook for the new USA and is expected to be highlighted by lower taxes, deregulation and fiscal expansion. The worry has been the trade policy but this will be more a renegotiation of existing trade agreements and more in the way of bi-lateral agreements.
Posted on 20 Jan
Le Cléac'h and Thomson revel in the Vendée Globe glory
Armel Le Cléac'h and Alex Thomson were basking in the glory of becoming the solo round the world race's fastest sailors. Armel Le Cléac'h and second-placed Alex Thomson were today basking in the glory of becoming the solo round the world race's fastest ever sailors. Le Cléac'h and Thomson arrived in the race's home port of Les Sables d'Olonne in France just 16 hours apart after more than 27,000 nautical miles of racing over 74 days to claim the top two podium places.
Posted on 20 Jan
Jules Verne Trophy – New equator record for IDEC Sport
Francis Joyon, Sébastien Audigane, Clément Surtel, Gwénolé Gahinet, Alex and Bernard achieved the best performance ever Francis Joyon, Sébastien Audigane, Clément Surtel, Gwénolé Gahinet, Alex Pella and Bernard Stamm achieved the best performance ever for the stretch betweenUshant and the Equator after rounding the three capes (Good Hope, Leeuwin and the Horn) with a time of 35 days, four hours and 45 minutes.
Posted on 20 Jan
Alex Thomson takes the runner-up spot in the Vendée Globe
Thomson set out to become the first Brit ever to win the Vendée Globe but following an epic battle with French skipper. Thomson, 42, set out to become the first Brit ever to win the Vendée Globe but following an epic battle with French skipper Armel Le Cléac'h missed out on the top spot by just shy of 16 hours. The skipper of Hugo Boss crossed the finish line at 0737 UTC in a time of 74 days, 19 hours, 35 minutes and 15 seconds in one of the closest finishes ever in the race's 27-year history.
Posted on 20 Jan
St. Maarten Heineken Regatta – Tweaks and changes
Paul Miller, Racing Director for the St. Maarten Heineken Regatta spoke about the tweaks and changes to the 37th edition Paul Miller, Racing Director for the St. Maarten Heineken Regatta, spoke about the tweaks and changes to the 37th edition of the St. Maarten Heineken Regatta, including free entry for the Gill Commodore's Cup, sensational Beach Cat packages including very attractive shipping costs from Europe and a novel finale to the Caribbean's most popular regatta.
Posted on 20 Jan
British Sailing Team confirms new teams for the new Olympic cycle
New crews, new faces and a potential future Olympian for 2040 are among the British Sailing Team updates New crews, new faces and a potential future Olympian for 2040 are among the British Sailing Team updates as the squad to kick-start the new Tokyo 2020 Olympic cycle is unveiled.
Posted on 20 Jan